Excessive Corporal Punishment In U.S.V.I

    (Picture below is of Yvonne Bowsky Elementary School, U.S.V.I)

      While doing my nightly reading (this time via the internet) I came across an article about one of our local elementary schools within the territory, Yvonne Bowsky Elementary School and couldn't resist reading about the latest news within the institution that inspires me so much. I always try to keep abreast of things happening within our territory's educational institutions, call it my way of staying informed. As I began to read this article I was confronted with many mixed emotions. First, I was happy to know that steps were finally being taken to rid our territory of such an unrealistic trait/ behavior for any educational professional since it was first off ridiculously bizarre ideal within educational guidelines and secondly we are in much more informed times, or at least I thought we were; after the article and attached video I wasn't to sure anymore. Next was fear to confront me, as I continued to read the article I realized that there had been an actual incident of this sort within the territory. In an effort not to become too overwhelmed I began to slightly rationalize the different situations in my head but everything I came up with was still bad. As the article came to a close I thought of two things; one I really do think that our new commissioner was much to light with the 'punishment' given for such an infraction especially since it was the vice principal of the school; a weeks suspension with pay and then a promotion to principal doesn't sent a good message. As noted within the same article featured within the St. Thomas Source and various others, such incidents do continue within the territory and abroad and reap the same horrid results. If the vice principal is allowed to get away with such behavior how do we really expect to deter others? Unfortunately it may actually be the only way for teachers to get a week off with pay. My second thought was about those present at the time of the incident; of everyone there including the person videotaping I wonder how many of them call themselves education professionals.

     Then I saw the video, and though it is merely 53 seconds long I found it chilling from beginning to end with terrifying screams. I figured the person videotaping either had my sentiments of not bearing to watch what they'd found after those horrid screams or they were too afraid of losing their job. Listening to that child scream and beg I wondered how I would feel know that was my child or even that my child could possibly be in such a situation, then my heart sunk and I felt ashamed for my territory; why would our lawmakers allow such an act to go seemingly unnoticed? I can appreciate the fact that since corporal punishment legally is still allowed within U.S.V.I schools that it was a large factor for consideration (with regards to those involved in the discussion making process). I'm also certain that tenure was also a matter of consideration since one does not become principal overnight; I'm sure the educator in question is no doubt an excellent one to be able to lead in such a capacity. But as someone held at such a high regard within the institution and society being idolized by students, parents and colleagues, one should continued to be held at such standards with regards to doing what is right and held accountable accordingly.

     According to the Global Initiative to End all Corporal Punishment Of Children and the overwhelming evidence that shows the harmful effects of corporal punishment show associations between corporal punishment and a wide range of negative outcomes, including; direct physical harm, negative impacts on mental and physical health, poor moral internalization, increased aggression in children, increased perpetration and experience of violence in adults, increased antisocial behavior, poor cognitive development, and damaged relationships.

     My thoughts then shifted back to the commissioners response to the video, a week off with pay and a promotion, and wondered if that had been her child in the video if she would've thought it appropriate.

The views expressed within the blog are solely those of Ms. Child Advocate and does not reflect on any of her affiliations. For more on the U.S Virgin Islands read Too Much Violence And Abuse In Our Schools, Too Much Violence: Shootings Near USVI Preschools, and Educational Institutions Need New Blood.

Guy Benjamin Elementary is Closing; What Now?

Guy Benjamin Elementary is Closing; What Now?

So in many recent reports that I've read the Department of Education is receiving a lot of ‘heat’ from the general public, and members of the St. John community. I completely understand it of course; I mean the situation is one that no one would have hoped for. The students, faculty, and staff at the Guy Benjamin Elementary School along with parents have long voiced their opinions and concerns about lack of support it receives, declining numbers, and more recently an ‘invisible operating budget’. The school closing didn’t really come as a surprise to many since there have been rumors of such all year since the removal of kindergarten and first grades to the Julius Sprauve Elementary School in Cruz Bay. So, exactly what is all the fuss about?

At a meeting held at Guy Benjamin School for parents and students on Monday, Education Commissioner and Superintendent gave the awaiting parents the daunting news they’d feared for so long. While education officials only cited one reason for closing the school, declining students and operating costs, all of the arguments coming from parents and even teachers involved had little to do with the benefit of students. Attendees of the meeting cited how the school has always met the standards of the AYP report, and that residents of Coral Bay would now have to ‘commute’ to Cruz Bay in defense of the children. Other concerns expressed pertained to the area of the school (being around bars) and the amount of funding being saved by closing the school.

Those remarks almost seem selfish to me. In a school that has been operating without a principal or ‘checkbook’ how parents can and teachers alike expect the institution to continue with the same results. And while there were a few in attendance, mostly those affiliated with the school, haven’t heard of any actions taken by the community or the parents of students at Guy Benjamin Elementary to thwart the long awaited decision of closing the school. I did however read reports of education officials urging residents of St. John to consider enrolling their children within Guy Benjamin to hinder the pending decision, but one can only assume it was to no avail since the enrollment ratio for the next school year compared to the last were still very slim    While all students can benefit from a lesser student to teacher ratio, parents and educators should look at the benefits of this merge;

·         With the space at the closing elementary school new, necessary programs like an head start or even a K-12 institution may be implemented (which is well needed on the island)

·         Funds saved by the department can be used to enhance student life on the island itself as well as at the remaining school

·         Education official spoke of transportation for students of Coral Bay to the Julius Sprauve school in Cruz Bay under the supervision of teachers/aids; that is much more than most, if not all of our students within this territory (At least in my own experience it is mainly/solely the bus driver) and abroad.

Anyone can appreciate that change can sometimes be challenging, especially for children so young, but as adults (teachers and parents) should consider working on making the transition easier for all involved and encouraging already discouraged students to look on the bright side of things, after all the children are the ones who are really being affected the most aren’t they?

For further readings on the U.S Virgin Islands on topics of education and our children please read “Alternatives to Suspensions and Expulsions”, “Families Matter for the Achievement and Development of Goals”; and “ So Carnival Warrants Closing School Now!?”

This blog post is the opinions of Ms. Child Advocate and does not reflect on the institution’s she is employed for nor is those she affiliated with through volunteer work or otherwise. For more opinions from us please visit our blog page usviearlychildhoodlearning.blogspot.com or email us at usvi.childhood.learning@gmail.com  and like us on Facebook or follow Ms. Child Advocate on Twitter.

How well do you know child's teachers?!

While taking my son on our usual route around a block in our neighborhood which houses a primary school and a head start (among what used to be) we both happened upon two things that astonished us both. The first was a tamarind tree that I used to frequent in my youth! While passing by what seemed to be a patch of trees I could help but pick up one off the ground to give my baby a taste, but he bit off more than he could chew literally! After seeing his excitement for a fruit he’d only tasted once, I decided to try the remainder for myself and boy was I happy. It had been so long since I’d tasted the fruit from ‘these’ trees that I had forgotten how truly sweet they were. While picking up more tamarinds to carry back home with us, or eat on the way, I happened upon my second surprise of the morning which was seemed as unpleasant as it felt uneasy for me to hear.

It was the sound of a woman yelling; yelling to what seemed as if it were the top of her lungs. Because of our initial distance we decided to move closer, contemplating on whether there were any reasons for the school to be conducting a program (of which such noise is customary due to microphones and speakers) although it was too soon to be an Easter program, but way too early to be anything else.  Upon our arrival at the back of the building I heard what I am ashamed to say was by ‘man’s definition’ a woman, a teacher, yelling at a student to the top of her lungs. While I was unaware of the actual/ initial reason for such I did ‘over hear’ hear telling ‘Jaquan’ to “look at me while I’m speaking to you”, “answer me”, and “I am the adult here”.

I swayed my head in dismay as I stood to listen and try to figure out which grade and teacher was this situation taking place? I knew that the school houses primary grades k-3 and most kindergarten classes where held in the same building, but so where a first grade and a computer lab of which all teachers and students have access to and utilize periodically according to schedules. No matter which way I played the scenario it just didn’t seem fit for a teacher to be yelling at primary students of this nature, especially within a classroom. As I stood listening to the ‘teacher’ in question I realized that I had been spotted by another teacher, of whom I’d like to believe was probably having the same thoughts with regards to the boisterous teacher alienating her student. As I walked away I could see the look of other staff members outside listening almost intently but not budging to intervene, I wondered how well do we really know our children’s teachers?